{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

The trend where American homes consistently sold for more than the previous year has come to an end after three years. Recent national data from October indicates the median sale price of homes has dipped slightly below last year's levels, marking the first yearly decrease since spring 2023. Simultaneously, the inventory of available homes has risen to levels not seen since early 2020, pending sales have dropped to a decade-low (excluding the early pandemic), and nearly 20% of listings have seen a price reduction.

On the other hand, borrowing costs have risen again. Current average rates for 30-year fixed mortgages have surged into the mid-7% range following a brief period of decrease. While this gives buyers some leverage, it also means that monthly payments can still be challenging for many households.

This unique situation presents an opportunity. Sellers are now receiving fewer offers and properties are remaining on the market longer, leading to a shift where list prices and terms are becoming more negotiable. If you're in the market for a home during this winter season, here are several aspects you might consider discussing with your agent and lender.

Understanding the Implications of a Mild Price Drop

A slight national price decline of under half a percent isn't indicative of a market crash, nor does it imply that prices are decreasing uniformly everywhere. Some high-value coastal areas with limited inventory continue to appreciate, while various significant metropolitan areas in the South and West have witnessed price drops of several percentage points from last year. The specifics of your local area are far more critical than national statistics.

National figures indicate a shift in market dynamics. With homes remaining on the market longer and more listings vying for fewer buyers, sellers are likely to be more open to negotiations. This newfound flexibility can reflect not only in the price but also in the terms of the agreement.

The Purchase Price is Just One Aspect to Consider

Many buyers zero in solely on the purchase price; however, in a climate of high interest rates, monthly payments and upfront cash obligations can carry more weight. A reduction in purchase price may only marginally impact your loan terms. Alternatives for budgeting could be more effective by employing funds in different areas. Typical negotiations in a slowing market may include:

  • A lower offer than the asking price
  • Seller contributions towards closing costs
  • Repairs completed prior to closing or a repair credit
  • Seller-sponsored funds to reduce your mortgage rate
  • Closing dates that align with your needs
  • Inclusions like appliances or window treatments

Your agent is familiar with local seller behaviors and can guide you on which areas might deserve more focus in your offer. The goal should be to prioritize what's most significant to you rather than attempting to negotiate all aspects.

Credits Toward Closing Costs Can Mitigate Financial Strain

Closing costs typically amount to a few percent of your loan plus your down payment. For many first-time buyers, accumulating the necessary funds can be particularly daunting. Through a seller credit, you can offset some of those expenses, ultimately reducing the cash you need at closing.

However, there are limitations. Various loan programs cap the amount a seller can contribute, typically ranging between 3% and 9% of the sale price based on the type of loan and the down payment size, and credits generally cannot surpass your actual closing costs. Make sure you understand your specific loan's parameters early on so that your offer remains compliant.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With rates exceeding 7%, one beneficial offer from a seller could involve assistance with your interest rate. There are primarily two forms of buydowns.

A permanent buydown indicates the use of discount points paid at closing to reduce your rate for the entirety of the loan term. Each point expenses 1% of the loan amount, and the subsequent rate decrease can differ by lender and current market status. If you plan to keep the mortgage long-term, this option might be advantageous.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, lowers your monthly payments for the first year or two. In one common model, the initial year sees a two-percentage-point reduction, followed by a one-point decrease in the second year, returning to the original rate thereafter. For a typical $350,000 30-year mortgage at approximately 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest start around $2,409. A temporary buydown could reduce your first-year payment to about $1,952 and the second year's to around $2,176, before shifting back to the full rate in year three. The cost for this structure might be just over $8,000, which a seller might prefer to cover rather than decreasing the sale price equivalently.

Bear in mind, a temporary buydown isn't a permanent solution. You must be comfortable with the full payment after the discount period ends, as lenders typically assess you based on that higher rate. Should rates decrease in the future, refinancing might become an option, but timing and occurrence cannot be guaranteed.

Don't Forego Inspections for Competitiveness

In previous heated markets, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limited their requests to secure a home. In today's slower market, there's less urgency to relinquish such protections. A comprehensive home inspection enables you to gauge the state of essential systems such as roofing, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and foundation integrity before finalizing your commitment.

Should the inspection reveal any issues, your agent can guide you on whether to request repairs, a price adjustment or a credit. Generally, credits are simpler than arranging for seller-managed repairs, as they allow you flexibility over who handles the work and how. However, the best approach will depend on the specific issues and your loan's requirements.

Ensure Your Financing is Solid Before Negotiating

Having negotiating strength serves little purpose if your financing isn't robust. A seller assessing multiple offers will typically prefer the buyer they believe is most likely to complete the transaction. Before you start seriously looking, acquire a full preapproval instead of merely a quick prequalification, determine your maximum comfortable monthly payment, not just the upper limit of your loan, and evaluate estimates from several lenders. Also, inquire how each lender would manage a seller credit or buydown to prevent surprises down the road.

Essential Questions to Cover With Your Agent

  • How long are properties in this area remaining available, and how frequently are prices being adjusted?
  • Would negotiating a price drop, a credit for closing costs, or a rate buydown best fit my financial needs?
  • How do the current condition and history of this home influence my negotiation leverage?
  • What contingencies should I incorporate into my offer to safeguard my interests?

The Final Takeaway

While a softer market might not equate to inexpensive purchasing, especially amid rising mortgage rates, it does provide prepared buyers with more chances to strike favorable deals. With proper financing in place, a clear understanding of your priorities, and expert advice from your agent and lender, you might be in a position to secure more advantageous terms than was feasible a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Floating Icon